Charlie Anderson of Good Pizza
What happens when an engineer quits his job, goes all-in on pizza, and builds a slice shop obsessed with consistency?
In this episode of What’s Good Dough, Eidref is with Charlie Anderson, founder of Good Pizza Cleveland, to talk about the real work behind opening a modern slice shop. From menu minimalism and workflow design to dough fermentation, content creation, and long-term vision, this is a deep dive into what it actually takes to make great pizza— consistently.
Highlights:2:05 – Building a New York-style slice shop in Cleveland
4:15 – Modern pizzeria branding & restaurant interior design strategy
6:00 – Why a 6-item pizza menu improves consistency and profitability
8:30 – Weighing pizza toppings for cost control & operational consistency
10:50 – Commercial pizza oven management: stone temp, bake time & workflow
13:40 – The realities of running a high-volume slice shop
15:30 – Quitting engineering to open a pizzeria full-time
18:10 – From pizza pop-ups to brick-and-mortar restaurant ownership
21:00 – Imposter syndrome as a pizza entrepreneur & content creator
24:10 – Reverse-engineering New York pizza & building a pizza YouTube channel
27:00 – Using Instagram & organic social media to grow a local restaurant
30:00 – Poolish vs straight dough: 73% hydration pizza dough formula
33:20 – Controlling dough temperature for consistent fermentation
36:10 – Two-stage dough balling technique for stronger pizza crust
40:00 – Why long fermentation doesn’t always mean better pizza
43:00 – How to identify over-proofed pizza dough in a restaurant setting
46:20 – Slice shop bottlenecks: staffing, speed & labor efficiency
50:00 – Increasing restaurant revenue through operational efficiency
Follow them:https://goodpizzacleveland.com/https://www.instagram.com/goodpizzacleveland/?hl=enhttps://www.tiktok.com/@goodpizzacleveland?lang=en
https://www.youtube.com/@GoodPizzaCleveland
Thank you to our show sponsors:
Bacio Cheese:
Corto:https://bit.ly/457DNII
Join my Instagram Community Channel: https://www.instagram.com/channel/AbbWnReTYIlCfO21/
Patreon Page: patreon.com/whatsgooddough
DM @whatsgooddoughhttps://www.instagram.com/whatsgooddough/email me: claire@whatsgooddough.com
Topic:
pizza podcast, what’s good dough podcast, good pizza cleveland, charlie anderson pizza, pizza business podcast, opening a pizzeria, slice shop business, modern pizzeria design, pizza dough fermentation, poolish pizza dough, high hydration pizza dough, new york style pizza, pizza consistency systems, restaurant workflow efficiency, small menu pizzeria, pizza by the slice, pizza oven management, pizza SOPs, scaling a restaurant, pizza content creation, restaurant social media strategy, pizza consulting, pizza entrepreneur story, food business podcast, behind the scenes pizzeria, pizza making process, dough fermentation tips, pizza equipment workflow, independent pizzeria, pizza industry insights
